Add kernel solid operations and complete Solid3D (create and rigid move)

An additive HostApi::solid_operation builds cadkernel primitives and applies
rigid transforms, verifying each result lifts back losslessly and refusing a
payload it cannot lift. Exposed as doc.solids in Python; Solid3D, Body and
Region are mapped read-only with the opaque payload preserved. The lifecycle
test passes through the real runner with analytic volumes and exact extents as
oracles, DWG and DXF reopen with re-edit, and undo restores exactly.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <[email protected]>
This commit is contained in:
Felix RiestraandClaude Sonnet 5 committed 2026-09-20 17:29:06 +02:00
1 parent 07fe739571
commit 04cd9e462d
18 files changed
+717 -13

No files matched your search

+2
View File
@@ -135,3 +135,5 @@ is refused with a clear message instead of being rewritten.
4. **Surface** (plane first).
Phase 1 alone would move Solid3D from blocked to complete-in-OCS.
**Status (2026-09-20): phase 1 is done.** `HostApi::solid_operation` (create primitive and rigid transform), the `doc.solids` Python API and `audit_python_solid3d_lifecycle_over_real_ipc` are in; Solid3D is complete, Body moves through the same channel. Design B was implemented as recommended. Booleans, Region creation and Surface remain.
+5 -4
View File
@@ -7,13 +7,13 @@ Build a general Python document model over the OCS host API for all **43 canvas
As of 20 September 2026, the working branch is `plugin/host-model-api` at
`a8dd3640` plus the Leader increment, published as draft PR
[#1391](https://github.com/HakanSeven12/OpenCADStudio/pull/1391). Host API is
v7. The Python feature has explicit writes for **38 of 43** canvas kinds: 36
are creatable (the legacy `Polyline` and `Ole2Frame` are update-only). This is **not** 38 completed
kinds: Tolerance, Shape, AttributeEntity, Hatch, MLine, Dimension, MultiLeader, Table, PolygonMesh, PolyfaceMesh, Mesh, Wipeout, Point, Line, Circle, Arc, Ellipse, LwPolyline, Spline, Text, MText, Ray, XLine, Solid and Face3D pass every completion gate; Insert now passes every gate too; the audited Polyline (update-only by decision), Polyline2D and Polyline3D pass every gate that their format allows.
v7. The Python feature has explicit writes for **41 of 43** canvas kinds: 37
are creatable (the legacy `Polyline`, `Ole2Frame`, `Body` and `Region` are update-only). This is **not** 41 completed
kinds: Tolerance, Shape, AttributeEntity, Hatch, MLine, Dimension, MultiLeader, Table, PolygonMesh, PolyfaceMesh, Mesh, Wipeout, Point, Line, Circle, Arc, Ellipse, LwPolyline, Spline, Text, MText, Ray, XLine, Solid, Face3D and Solid3D pass every completion gate; Insert now passes every gate too; the audited Polyline (update-only by decision), Polyline2D and Polyline3D pass every gate that their format allows.
AttributeDefinition passes its host and real IPC lifecycle but remains short of
`Complete` because the previously pinned CAD codec dropped optional ATTDEF
fields during DXF reads; revalidate that blocker against the current
`acadrust` revision `7ea4247`. Leader is mapped and integration-tested but blocked at W by three acadrust persistence gaps (see the ledger). Leader, Helix, Underlay, ViewBorder and Light are mapped and integration-tested but blocked at W by acadrust persistence gaps, and RasterImage and Viewport are held short of `Complete` by unverifiable or missing oracles (see the ledger). RasterImage is mapped and integration-tested, held short of `Complete` by unverifiable image-dictionary linkage. The other 5 canvas kinds (SectionSymbol, Region, Body, Solid3D, Surface) have only `layer` and are recorded as blocked
`acadrust` revision `7ea4247`. Leader is mapped and integration-tested but blocked at W by three acadrust persistence gaps (see the ledger). Leader, Helix, Underlay, ViewBorder and Light are mapped and integration-tested but blocked at W by acadrust persistence gaps, and RasterImage and Viewport are held short of `Complete` by unverifiable or missing oracles (see the ledger). RasterImage is mapped and integration-tested, held short of `Complete` by unverifiable image-dictionary linkage. The remaining two canvas kinds have only `layer`: SectionSymbol (blocked) and Surface (unblocked by design)
writes through the document model. All 43 have raw typed snapshots. There are
three internal records and two opaque fallbacks outside the 43 canvas kinds.
@@ -177,3 +177,4 @@ exact queue above and update statuses with evidence after each increment.
- Wrote up the cadcodec DXF reader gaps as draft issues in [cadcodec-reader-gaps.md](cadcodec-reader-gaps.md) (nothing filed): ATTDEF, boolean groups read through `as_i16()`, UNDERLAY rotation units, LEADER, DRAWINGVIEW/SECTIONLINE dispatch and TABLE merged ranges. Verifying them corrected an earlier attribution: the Spline "DXF drops weights" finding was an OCS bug (the writer emits weights only for a rational spline), now fixed by setting `flags.rational` from the weights, so Spline is complete.
- Mapped `Ole2Frame` as update-only (queue item 21, previously blocked). OCS already builds real embedded frames (`build_embedded_ole`), which supplied the fixture the blocker was waiting for. Frame corners and the aspect lock are scriptable; the opaque storage and envelope are excluded and refused on edit. The audit proves the embedded picture survives DWG and DXF unchanged. Creation from Python remains a follow-up. The remaining blocked kinds are SectionSymbol, Region, Body, Solid3D and Surface.
- Investigated the cadkernel path for the ACIS kinds ([cadkernel-body-path.md](cadkernel-body-path.md)). The earlier "blocked" reasoning was overstated: OCS already builds primitives, transforms bodies and runs booleans through cadkernel, and `solid_to_sat` plus `kernel_acis_body` verify each result lifts back with no loss. Two `#[ignore]` spike tests measured exact volumes and DWG and DXF round trips for a box, moved, rotated and mirrored copies, three booleans, four other primitives and a `Body` entity. The real gap is an operation channel from a script to that pipeline; the note recommends an additive `solid_operation` host method and a phased plan (Solid3D create and transform, then booleans and Body, then Region, then Surface). Booleans took about 23 s each in a debug build and need release timing first. Region, Body, Solid3D and Surface move from blocked to unblocked-by-design; SectionSymbol stays blocked.
- Built the cadkernel operation channel and completed `Solid3D` (create and rigid move). `HostApi::solid_operation` is additive (default "unsupported"), so older hosts and plugins are unaffected; it travels as `PluginRequest::SolidOperation` and `PluginResponse::SolidResult`, and the host records its own undo step only after validation so a refused operation leaves nothing behind. The Python surface is `doc.solids.*`. Every result is verified lossless by the kernel path before it is accepted and a payload that will not lift is refused untouched. `Body` moves through the same channel and `Region` is accepted but untested. Booleans, Region creation from curves and Surface remain, in that order; booleans wait on release-build timing. Solid3D, Body and Region are now mapped read-only with the opaque payload excluded and preserved.
+4 -4
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
# OCS canvas kind coverage ledger
Use with [the completion plan](plugin-host-model-completion-plan.md). This ledger is current as of 20 September 2026: **38 of 43 canvas kinds have explicit geometry writes** (36 creatable, plus update-only legacy `Polyline` and `Ole2Frame`), **26 kinds are complete**, and 5 remain layer-only and blocked (SectionSymbol, Region, Body, Solid3D, Surface). `Mapped` means at least one non-layer field is exposed for Python writes; it does **not** mean the kind passes the completion gate. `Update-only` means Python creation is unavailable. `Layer-only` means raw inspection and canvas layer edits exist, but geometry is not mapped. Record actual evidence or a blocking issue before changing any status to `Complete`.
Use with [the completion plan](plugin-host-model-completion-plan.md). This ledger is current as of 20 September 2026: **41 of 43 canvas kinds have explicit geometry writes** (37 creatable, plus update-only legacy `Polyline`, `Ole2Frame`, `Body` and `Region`), **27 kinds are complete**, and 2 remain layer-only (SectionSymbol blocked, Surface unblocked by design). `Mapped` means at least one non-layer field is exposed for Python writes; it does **not** mean the kind passes the completion gate. `Update-only` means Python creation is unavailable. `Layer-only` means raw inspection and canvas layer edits exist, but geometry is not mapped. Record actual evidence or a blocking issue before changing any status to `Complete`.
Completion gate codes: **C** = create through Python document model; **R** = read; **E** = edit defining geometry and another property; **D** = delete; **U** = undo/redo and atomic failure; **I** = real IPC plus GUI/canvas pick or observable behavior; **W** = DWG and DXF save/reopen; **V** = invalid-input checks and untouched-field/reference preservation; **P** = build and load the in-tree bundled plugin with a manifest matching the host toolchain and acadrust source. A kind is `Complete` only when **C/R/E/D/U/I/W/V/P** all pass and its property catalog matches implementation. `Blocked` requires a specific dependency or failing fixture.
@@ -44,9 +44,9 @@ Completion gate codes: **C** = create through Python document model; **R** = rea
| ViewBorder | **Integration-tested / blocked at W by acadrust (DXF kind)** | Writable: `min`, `max`, `center` (2-D pairs), `scale`, `rotation_angle`, `active_viewport` and `scale_handle` (both required at creation). `version` is read-only. Reference rules: `active_viewport` must be an existing Viewport entity and `scale_handle` an existing `Scale` object. Host validation requires finite bounds with `min` below `max` on both axes, a positive scale and a finite rotation. `staged_python_view_border_lifecycle_over_real_ipc` (shared `run_mesh_lifecycle`, driver-made viewport and scale fixtures) passes C/R/E/D/U/I/V/P and DWG W: creation, a resize/recenter/scale/rotation transaction, canvas wires, seven rejection cases plus an atomic rollback, DWG reopen and re-edit, and three-step undo/redo. **W blocker (engine, pinned by a canary):** a DXF `DRAWINGVIEW` reopens as a different, opaque entity kind rather than as a ViewBorder, so only DWG restores the typed record. Not `Complete` until DXF loading restores the typed entity. Not covered: the linked view representation and drawing-view definition records. |
| SectionSymbol | **Blocked** | Not mapped. A valid section mark needs a `SectionViewStyle` and a `ViewRep` view-representation object that a script cannot create through the host API, and the entity stores raw point counts and flag words (`raw_point_count_90`, `raw_flags_90`, `raw_point_record_count`, `raw_view_symbol_70`) whose relationship to `points` is undocumented in acadrust and is written back verbatim by both writers, so the host cannot keep them consistent after a scripted edit without guessing. Adding the kind needs (1) host-side creation or lookup of a section style and view representation, and (2) a confirmed derivation of the raw counts from a real DWG produced by another CAD application. The kind keeps raw snapshot access and layer edits. |
| Light | **Integration-tested / blocked at W by acadrust (DXF `cast_shadows`)** | Writable: `name`, `light_type` (1 distant, 2 point, 3 spot), `position`, `target`, `status`, `light_color`, `plot_glyph`, `intensity`, the attenuation type and limits, `hotspot_angle`, `falloff_angle`, `cast_shadows`, `shadow_type`, `shadow_map_size`, `shadow_map_softness`, `photometric_mode`, `photometric_data`; `class_version` is read-only. Host validation requires a non-empty name, a known light type, finite placement, a spot or distant target that differs from the position, non-negative intensity, angles and limits, an attenuation start not above its end, a spot hotspot not above its falloff, and a non-negative shadow map size. `staged_python_light_lifecycle_over_real_ipc` (shared `run_mesh_lifecycle`) passes C/R/E/D/U/I/V/P and DWG W: a spot light with an RGB colour, an intensity/target/position/shadow transaction that preserves the colour and untouched fields, the canvas glyph, eight rejection cases plus an atomic rollback, DWG reopen and re-edit, and three-step undo/redo. **W blocker (engine, pinned by a canary):** the DXF reader does not restore `cast_shadows`, which reopens false; colour, placement and intensity persist. Not covered: photometric web data edits and sun/skylight objects. |
| Region | **Blocked, unblocked by design** | Not mapped yet. Transform uses the same pipeline; creation needs a "region from these curve handles" operation built on the REGION command's `add_region_model`. See [cadkernel-body-path.md](cadkernel-body-path.md). |
| Body | **Blocked, unblocked by design** | Not mapped yet. Same pipeline as Solid3D: `kernel_acis_body` lifts a `Body` payload and the spike round-tripped it through DWG and DXF. A genuinely non-solid (sheet or wire) body may not lift and would stay layer-only. See [cadkernel-body-path.md](cadkernel-body-path.md). |
| Solid3D | **Blocked, unblocked by design** | Not mapped yet. The 2026-09-20 kernel investigation ([cadkernel-body-path.md](cadkernel-body-path.md)) shows OCS already creates the payload (nine primitives), transforms it and combines bodies through cadkernel, and that `solid_to_sat` and `kernel_acis_body` verify every result lifts back with no loss; spikes confirmed exact volumes and DWG and DXF round trips. What is missing is a script-to-host operation channel (recommended: an additive `solid_operation` host method covering create-primitive, transform and boolean), not geometry. Open items: boolean speed (about 23 s in a debug build, unmeasured in release), history-carrying solids, and AutoCAD acceptance, which cannot be tested here. |
| Region | **Mapped read-only; transform untested** | Mapped like Solid3D and accepted by `doc.solids.transform`, which lifts the payload with `kernel_acis_body`, but no Region fixture exercises it yet. Creation from curve handles (the REGION command's `add_region_model`) is the next operation to add. |
| Body | **Integration-tested (rigid move only)** | Mapped read-only like Solid3D (same payload container). `audit_python_body_transform_over_real_ipc` moves a Body carrying a kernel box through `doc.solids.translate`, checks the exact extent, DWG reopen with a losslessly lifting payload and the exact volume, and the explanatory refusal of `create_entity('Body')`. Scripts cannot create a Body, and a non-solid (sheet or wire) body that does not lift is refused untouched. |
| Solid3D | **Complete (create + rigid move)** | New in this session: an additive `HostApi::solid_operation` (`SolidOperation::Create` and `Transform`, plus a `SolidPrimitive` enum) carried by `PluginRequest::SolidOperation` / `PluginResponse::SolidResult` through both IPC clients, the server and `HostSession`, and a Python `doc.solids` API: `box`, `wedge`, `cylinder`, `sphere`, `torus`, `pyramid`, `transform`, `translate`, `rotate`, `mirror`. The host builds bodies with cadkernel, and every result goes through `solid_to_sat`, which lifts its own output back and refuses anything lossy. A transform first lifts the existing payload with `kernel_acis_body` and is refused, leaving the payload untouched, when that is lossy. Only rigid moves and mirrors are accepted (scaling and shear are refused). Regenerated `wires` follow the body, `silhouettes` are cleared and `history_handle` is dropped. Python sees `uid`, `point_of_reference` and `history_handle` read-only; `acis_data`, `wires` and `silhouettes` are excluded and preserved; creation through `create_entity` is refused with a message pointing at `doc.solids`. `audit_python_solid3d_lifecycle_over_real_ipc` passes C/R/E/D/U/I/W/V/P through the real runner with the kernel as oracle: all six primitives match their analytic volumes (box, wedge and cube exactly, curved solids within 2 percent of the tessellated volume), a translate, a rotate and a mirror keep the volume and move the extent exactly and keep 12 edge wires, 13 refusals (zero and non-finite sizes, a torus with minor above major, too few pyramid sides, an empty layer, an unknown primitive, a wrong number count, a scaling matrix, a non-finite offset, a payload the kernel cannot lift, a missing entity) change nothing and leave no undo step, DWG and DXF reopen with the payload lifting losslessly and the same volume and extent, a reopened payload moves again, and undo restores the original solid exactly. Not covered: booleans (about 23 s each in a debug build; release timing needed first), solids that carry parametric history, and AutoCAD acceptance of the written payload, which cannot be tested here. |
| Surface | **Blocked, unblocked by design** | Not mapped yet, and the most involved: a surface carries `surface_data` beside `acis_data`, and only a plane keeps its kind when regenerated. Plan: planes first, then extruded and revolved from a profile. See [cadkernel-body-path.md](cadkernel-body-path.md). |
| Ole2Frame | **Update-only (all applicable gates pass)** | Writable: `upper_left_corner`, `lower_right_corner`, `lock_aspect`, `is_paper_space`. Read-only: `version`, `source_application`, `ole_object_type`, `dwg_mode`. The embedded object `storage` and the frame `envelope` are opaque, excluded from the Python form, refused by the mutation check (`Ole2Frame embedded storage cannot change`) and preserved untouched. Host validation requires finite corners spanning a nonzero width and height and `lock_aspect` of 0 or 1. Creation from a script is refused with an explanatory message, because a valid frame needs a real embedded object; the host's own `build_embedded_ole` builds one from an image. `audit_python_ole2frame_lifecycle_over_real_ipc` (shared driver; the fixture embeds a real 4x3 PNG through `add_embedded_image`) passes E/D/U/I/W/V/P: a corner and aspect-lock transaction, canvas geometry, rejection of a zero-size frame, a bad aspect lock, non-finite corners, a read-only `version` and an attempt to write `storage`, an atomic rollback, **DWG and DXF reopen with the 119-byte embedded picture byte-for-byte intact (extracted through `extract_presentation`)**, re-edit, and two-step undo/redo. Not `Complete` because Python cannot create a frame. A create path (`file_path` of an image, built with `build_embedded_ole`) would need a manual-kind converter like Dimension and is the natural follow-up. |
+2 -2
View File
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ attached attribute and sequence records. Those fields report `transaction_geomet
catalog. All 43 canvas kinds also support nonempty `layer` changes through
the same undoable transaction; internal and opaque variants remain read-only
through the document model. The adapter accepts only `layer` patches for
canvas kinds outside its 38 geometry converters. Other writable properties
canvas kinds outside its 41 geometry converters. Other writable properties
still report `type_conversion_only`; broader CAD range and cross-property
checks remain outstanding.
The host's `entity_snapshot` helper serializes any typed entity as a detached
@@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ Input tokens are bound to the drawing tab that requested the pick. Polling a
token from another tab returns no result and does not consume it.
Python `doc.entities[handle]` returns a descriptor for every entity. For kinds
outside the 38-kind generated schema it contains only handle, kind, and layer;
outside the 41-kind generated schema it contains only handle, kind, and layer;
`layer` is editable on canvas kinds. `doc.coverage()` enumerates the
catalog; `doc.coverage("Line")` and `line.coverage` return one entry. For
covered kinds, the coverage object lists actual readable and editable