forked from 1b-agent/fieldcraft-upstream
de8c0e2700
* docs: verification and validation against theory, experiments and published benchmarks; fixtures Owner decision 2026-10-13: test against experimental and theoretical data; results published by vendors (e.g. Abaqus benchmark and verification manuals) may be used as cited reference values for our own models of the same problems; once a case matches, its result becomes a fixture so fidelity cannot regress. Commercial products are still never run and their files and text never copied. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NmAttHhUZTokgPeEJia8sm * docs: V&V policy in AGENTS.md, ADR 0001 and the roadmap Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NmAttHhUZTokgPeEJia8sm --------- Co-authored-by: jyviko <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
104 lines
6.9 KiB
Markdown
104 lines
6.9 KiB
Markdown
# ADR 0001: Libraries and licences
|
||
|
||
Status: accepted (2026-10-13)
|
||
|
||
## Context
|
||
|
||
ModelCraft is MIT OR Apache-2.0. Everything it links must allow that, and the meshing and solver
|
||
algorithms, where the obvious open-source implementations are GPL-family, must come from papers.
|
||
|
||
## Decision
|
||
|
||
**Geometry: SolidCraft**, as git dependencies pinned by rev (`solidcraft-kernel`,
|
||
`solidcraft-geom`, `solidcraft-doc`, `solidcraft-io`; MIT OR Apache-2.0, built on the Apache-2.0
|
||
truck crates). SolidCraft is the primary geometry source: ModelCraft opens SolidCraft designs and
|
||
meshes from SolidCraft's tessellation, and reads face-tagged meshes SolidCraft exports. Other CAD
|
||
exchange files (STEP, which SolidCraft's kernel already reads) can be added as secondary inputs
|
||
through the same crate. Only `modelcraft-geometry` may depend on SolidCraft.
|
||
|
||
**Meshing: our own**, implemented from published papers (`docs/meshing/literature.md`).
|
||
Robust predicates follow Shewchuk's adaptive-precision arithmetic (the paper; his reference
|
||
`predicates.c` is public domain). A permissive crate may be adopted instead after review; record
|
||
it here. *Decided 2026-10-13:* our own implementation, `modelcraft_mesh::predicates`, written from
|
||
Shewchuk 1997, Devillers–Teillaud 2011 and Attene 2020 (no `unsafe`, deterministic, wasm-safe, a
|
||
validated coordinate domain instead of Shewchuk's overflow/underflow caveat, and indirect
|
||
predicates that `robust` lacks). `robust` (georust, MIT OR Apache-2.0) and `num-bigint` /
|
||
`num-rational` / `num-traits` (MIT OR Apache-2.0) are dev-dependencies only: differential test
|
||
oracles, never linked into ModelCraft.
|
||
|
||
**Linear algebra: our own.** *Decided 2026-10-13 (implicit solver task):* `modelcraft-solver`
|
||
has its own sparse symmetric storage, nested-dissection ordering (George 1973, by coordinate
|
||
bisection), up-looking sparse Cholesky (Davis 2006, elimination trees per Liu 1990) and
|
||
shift-invert block Lanczos with full reorthogonalization (Ericsson–Ruhe 1980, Grimes–Lewis–Simon
|
||
1994) on a Householder + implicit-QR dense eigensolver (Golub–Van Loan). `faer` (MIT) was the
|
||
alternative and is faster on large problems, but it selects SIMD kernels by CPU feature at run
|
||
time (AVX2, AVX-512, NEON), which changes floating-point reduction order between machines and
|
||
breaks the bit-for-bit determinism rule; it is also a large dependency tree for the browser
|
||
build. Our code is sequential with a fixed operation order, `unsafe`-free and wasm-safe, and its
|
||
factor size is known (and capped) before any value is computed. Cost if this is wrong: large
|
||
models (beyond a few hundred thousand equations) factor slower than they could; the remedy is a
|
||
supernodal factorization of our own, or `faer` behind the same `Factor` interface with a stated
|
||
tolerance instead of bit-identity, as the GPU exception already does.
|
||
|
||
**Allowed:** MIT, BSD-2/3, Apache-2.0, ISC, Zlib, Unicode, MPL-2.0 (as an unmodified dependency),
|
||
CC0 and public domain.
|
||
|
||
**Rejected — never read, copy or link:**
|
||
|
||
| Project | Licence | Would have offered |
|
||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| TetGen | AGPL-3.0 | constrained Delaunay tetrahedralization |
|
||
| CGAL | GPL-3.0 / LGPL-3.0 | Delaunay, mesh generation |
|
||
| Gmsh | GPL-2.0+ | tet and hex meshing |
|
||
| Netgen | LGPL-2.1 | tet meshing |
|
||
| CalculiX | GPL-2.0 | implicit solver, Abaqus-like input |
|
||
| Code_Aster | GPL-3.0 | implicit solver |
|
||
| OpenRadioss | AGPL-3.0 | explicit solver |
|
||
| Elmer | GPL-2.0 / LGPL-2.1 | multiphysics solver |
|
||
| FreeFEM, Salome | LGPL | FE libraries, pre-processing |
|
||
| Palabos, OpenLB, waLBerla, lbmpy, VirtualFluids, TCLB | AGPL / GPL | lattice Boltzmann (implement from the papers) |
|
||
| OpenFOAM, SU2, 4C, DualSPHysics, preCICE | GPL / LGPL | CFD, FSI coupling, SPH |
|
||
| FluidX3D | non-commercial only | GPU lattice Boltzmann |
|
||
| LULESH | no licence | explicit hydrodynamics proxy |
|
||
| OpenCASCADE | LGPL-2.1 | B-rep kernel |
|
||
| Attene's CDT, Indirect_Predicates, VolumeMesher | GPL / LGPL | robust CDT, indirect predicates (implement from the papers) |
|
||
| TetWild (original), Evocube, robustPolycube, ultimaille, invertible-maps | GPL-3.0 / AGPL-3.0 | tet meshing, polycube, injective maps |
|
||
| libHexEx, libHexHex, QGP3D, MC3D, CoMISo, Graphite | GPL | integer-grid-map hex extraction, quantization |
|
||
| Shewchuk's Triangle | non-commercial only | 2D meshing |
|
||
| geogram `third_party/tetgen`, `third_party/triangle` and their wrappers | AGPL / non-commercial | (the rest of geogram is BSD-3 and readable) |
|
||
| libigl `copyleft/` modules | GPL | (libigl core is MPL-2.0 and readable) |
|
||
| OpenVolumeMesh, CGoGN | believed LGPL, unverified | treat as forbidden until checked |
|
||
|
||
deal.II is now dual-licensed Apache-2.0 (with LLVM exception) or LGPL, so it is readable under its Apache-2.0 option. Readable solver references (re-implement from the papers): STLBM (MIT), XLB, lettuce, pylbm, Laghos, MFEM, IBAMR, the Kratos core, MUI, FEBio, SPHinXsys, SPlisHSPlasH, fenris; full table in `docs/solvers/literature.md`.
|
||
|
||
**Repositories without a licence are all rights reserved: never read them** (for example Gao
|
||
2019's octree hex code, LoopyCuts). Readable references for the meshing work (re-implement from
|
||
the paper, note anything adapted in ATTRIBUTION.md): Shewchuk's `predicates.c` (public domain),
|
||
`georust/robust` (Apache-2.0), geogram (BSD-3, exclusions above), fTetWild (MPL-2.0), CinoLib,
|
||
Gen-Adapt-Ref, HexaLab, robust_hex_dominant_meshing (MIT), quartet (ISC). The full table with
|
||
sources is in `docs/meshing/literature.md`.
|
||
|
||
**Test geometry** follows the same rule as test data: nothing produced with a commercial CAD or
|
||
CAE product. That excludes ABC (Onshape), MAMBO (files from commercial translators) and the HexMe
|
||
models that come from ABC, GrabCAD or Siemens NX; HexMe's Gmsh-made models are allowed (CC-BY-4.0).
|
||
Thingi10K is not used either (owner decision 2026-10-13: authoring tools unrecorded). **The test
|
||
corpus is our own:** parts built with SolidCraft (scripts or designs authored in SolidCraft,
|
||
committed as their recipes so the geometry is regenerated, not stored) and analytic shapes.
|
||
Recipes are SolidCraft command scripts run through `solidcraft-engine` (same pinned rev), a
|
||
dependency of `modelcraft-geometry` only behind its non-default `scripts` feature, which the test
|
||
tooling (`modelcraft-testkit`) enables; the shipped library opens designs without it.
|
||
|
||
**Commercial products** (Abaqus, Nastran, LS-DYNA, LS-PrePost, HyperMesh, ANSA, Femap, Patran,
|
||
ANSYS) are never run or scripted, and their input files, text and figures are never copied. Deck
|
||
formats come from the vendors' public reference manuals, described in our own words with our own
|
||
examples. Published numerical results (benchmark and verification manuals) may serve as cited
|
||
reference values for our own models of the same problems (owner decision 2026-10-13;
|
||
docs/verification.md).
|
||
|
||
## Consequences
|
||
|
||
- The tet and hex meshers are significant original work; the literature survey decides the
|
||
order and the methods.
|
||
- SolidCraft and ModelCraft move together: bumping the pinned rev bumps the repeated
|
||
`[patch.crates-io]` entries in the same commit.
|